Lab032: evaluate FEC block parameters

PROJECT_LOG.md

@@ -139,3 +139,27 @@ git version 2.51.1.windows.1
 - D=2 сохранён как резервный вариант.
 - D=4 и D=8 исключены из основной линии разработки.
 - Следующая лабораторная подбирает размер блока и количество проверочных пакетов.
+
+---
+
+# Запись 007
+
+## Дата
+
+29 июля 2026 года
+
+## Тема
+
+Завершение Lab032: параметры блочного исправления потерянных пакетов.
+
+## Выполнено
+
+- Исследованы параметры блочного исправления потерянных пакетов.
+- Сравнивались режимы без исправления, 4+1, 8+2, 12+3, 6+2, 8+3, 4+2 и 8+4.
+- Режим 12+3 выбран основным.
+- Его транспортный поток составляет 226,951 кбит/с.
+- Запас до контрольных 300 кбит/с составляет 73,049 кбит/с.
+- Режим 8+4 оставлен усиленным экспериментальным вариантом.
+- Режим 8+3 не принят из-за отсутствия устойчивого преимущества.
+- Подтверждено, что продолжительные помехи нельзя компенсировать только увеличением числа проверочных пакетов.
+- Следующий этап посвящён совместной передаче команд, телеметрии и видео с приоритетным обслуживанием.

data/processed/lab032/lab032_report.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,101 @@
+Lab032. Подбор параметров блочного исправления потерь
+
+Исходный профиль и неизменные слои
+- Видео: data\raw\lab026_rover_source.mp4
+- 63 реальных пар BASE/ROI, 3 fps; длительность 20.766667 с.
+- BASE 240x135 grayscale JPEG Q23; ROI 320x180 grayscale JPEG Q33.
+- Внутренний Lab028 packet: payload 512 байт; внешний формат и GF(256) Lab030 не изменены.
+- Глубина D=1: systematic symbols блока передаются первыми, затем parity; перемежение отсутствует.
+- Блоки формируются из непрерывного потока внутренних пакетов и могут пересекать composite_frame_id.
+
+Последний неполный блок
+- Используется единое правило:
+  r_last = max(1, ceil(k_last × r / k)).
+- Нулевое дополнение существует только внутри математики GF(256); внешние пакеты синтетически не добавляются.
+
+Сравнительная таблица восьми режимов
+mode | rate | outer/margin kbit/s | composite 10/50/200/1000 ms | pub p95 200 ms s | no-image p95 200 ms s | block mean/max ms | decode mean ms | queue mean/max
+----:|-----:|----------------------:|----------------------------:|-------------------:|------------------------:|------------------:|---------------:|---------------:
+Без FEC | 1.000000 | 168.396/131.604 | 0.669603/0.914524/0.960714/0.979762 | 0.203013 | 1.325184 | 0.000/0.000 | 0.000 | 13.717/15
+4+1 | 0.800000 | 226.951/73.049 | 0.791429/0.909048/0.959683/0.978175 | 0.274880 | 1.337167 | 92.966/189.840 | 77.606 | 17.171/20
+8+2 | 0.800000 | 226.951/73.049 | 0.912857/0.933333/0.963016/0.978333 | 0.275067 | 1.338747 | 189.723/266.720 | 159.003 | 17.210/21
+12+3 | 0.800000 | 226.951/73.049 | 0.951984/0.951190/0.965714/0.978492 | 0.288773 | 1.339135 | 288.795/337.173 | 242.715 | 17.219/21
+6+2 | 0.750000 | 242.928/57.072 | 0.920873/0.930317/0.961270/0.978254 | 0.294080 | 1.333927 | 142.659/214.293 | 111.939 | 18.337/21
+8+3 | 0.727273 | 250.916/49.084 | 0.963413/0.948810/0.962540/0.978175 | 0.305947 | 1.339067 | 191.857/266.720 | 145.777 | 18.985/24
+4+2 | 0.666667 | 274.659/25.341 | 0.924762/0.924127/0.959048/0.977143 | 0.336320 | 1.349667 | 96.393/159.120 | 65.744 | 20.698/24
+8+4 | 0.666667 | 274.659/25.341 | 0.986984/0.955317/0.963095/0.978175 | 0.336667 | 1.347973 | 193.876/266.720 | 132.578 | 20.859/26
+
+Подробные результаты при средней Bad 200 мс
+mode | BASE/ROI/composite | blocks ok/fail | restored packets | delivered kbit/s | publication mean/p95/max s | no-image mean/p95/max s | incomplete mean/p95/max
+----:|-------------------:|---------------:|-----------------:|-----------------:|--------------------------:|-----------------------:|------------------------:
+Без FEC | 0.972302/0.967302/0.960714 | 0.000000/0.000000 | 0 | 150.881 | 0.185098/0.203013/0.209680 | 0.786259/1.325184/2.333307 | 1.387/3.000/6
+4+1 | 0.973175/0.966905/0.959683 | 0.975972/0.024028 | 92 | 150.067 | 0.246589/0.274880/0.394773 | 0.823033/1.337167/2.349520 | 1.494/3.000/6
+8+2 | 0.974841/0.969365/0.963016 | 0.972130/0.027870 | 144 | 150.483 | 0.246330/0.275067/0.466747 | 0.837464/1.338747/2.334160 | 1.528/3.000/6
+12+3 | 0.975794/0.971270/0.965714 | 0.968403/0.031597 | 260 | 150.899 | 0.246565/0.288773/0.522907 | 0.841596/1.339135/2.380240 | 1.543/3.000/6
+6+2 | 0.973651/0.968571/0.961270 | 0.975243/0.024757 | 188 | 150.202 | 0.262330/0.294080/0.425493 | 0.839718/1.333927/2.364880 | 1.544/3.000/6
+8+3 | 0.974603/0.969524/0.962540 | 0.973981/0.026019 | 249 | 150.081 | 0.271028/0.305947/0.466747 | 0.861515/1.339067/2.334160 | 1.589/3.000/6
+4+2 | 0.973095/0.966429/0.959048 | 0.978287/0.021713 | 236 | 149.535 | 0.296583/0.336320/0.394773 | 0.865525/1.349667/2.364880 | 1.613/3.000/6
+8+4 | 0.975238/0.970238/0.963095 | 0.975833/0.024167 | 375 | 149.944 | 0.295920/0.336667/0.465947 | 0.899563/1.347973/2.334160 | 1.703/3.000/6
+
+Временная модель и очередь
+- Непрерывные чередующиеся экспоненциальные Good/Bad интервалы Lab029B, средняя доля Bad около 2%.
+- Средние Bad 10, 50, 200 и 1000 мс; 200 повторов; fixed seeds 300300...300303.
+- Пакет теряется при любом пересечении передачи с Bad. FIFO учитывает фактическую длину каждого внешнего пакета и скорость 300 кбит/с.
+- Все исследованные режимы остаются ниже 300 кбит/с; положительный запас показан в таблице. Отдельная функциональная проверка ускоряет поток 8+4 вдвое и подтверждает реальное накопление очереди при перегрузке.
+- Block duration измеряется от начала первого до конца последнего символа. Decode-ready без потерь — от начала первого до конца k-го systematic symbol.
+
+1. Одинаковая кодовая скорость 0.8: 4+1, 8+2 и 12+3
+- 4+1: outer 226.951 кбит/с, block mean 92.966 мс, decode-ready 77.606 мс, composite@200 0.959683.
+- 8+2: outer 226.951 кбит/с, block mean 189.723 мс, decode-ready 159.003 мс, composite@200 0.963016.
+- 12+3: outer 226.951 кбит/с, block mean 288.795 мс, decode-ready 242.715 мс, composite@200 0.965714.
+- При одинаковой номинальной code rate длина блока меняет временное окно, в котором одна помеха может собрать несколько стираний. Короткий блок раньше получает k systematic symbols и быстрее допускает декодирование.
+- Длинный блок дольше остаётся открытым и может включить больше потерянных пакетов одной длительной помехи; при этом его больший абсолютный r иногда полезен для рассеянных стираний.
+
+2. Одинаковая code rate 2/3: 4+2 и 8+4
+- 4+2: outer 274.659 кбит/с, composite@200 0.959048, publication P95 0.336320 с, no-image P95 1.349667 с.
+- 8+4: outer 274.659 кбит/с, composite@200 0.963095, publication P95 0.336667 с, no-image P95 1.347973 с.
+- Сравнение изолирует влияние длины блока при одинаковой сильной избыточности: короткий 4+2 быстрее закрывается, длинный 8+4 имеет больше абсолютных parity symbols, но дольше накапливает стирания.
+
+3. Влияние увеличения r
+- Большее r позволяет исправить больше стираний, но увеличивает внешний поток, служебную долю, время передачи блока и публикационную задержку.
+- 8+3: outer 250.916 кбит/с (8+2 226.951, 8+4 274.659); composite@200 0.962540 (8+2 0.963016, 8+4 0.963095); P95 delay 0.305947 с (8+2 0.275067, 8+4 0.336667).
+- Поэтому 8+3 оценивается по фактическому положению между 8+2 и 8+4 сразу по скорости, устойчивости и задержке, без автоматического назначения рабочим режимом.
+
+4. Практическая граница без автоматического выбора
+- Минимальный поток: Без FEC, 168.396 кбит/с.
+- Максимальная composite-устойчивость при Bad 200 мс: 12+3, 0.965714.
+- Минимальная P95-задержка среди защищённых режимов: 4+1, 0.274880 с.
+- Недоминируемые по outer bitrate↓, publication P95↓ и composite success↑ режимы при Bad 200 мс: Без FEC, 8+2, 12+3.
+- Это набор компромиссов, а не автоматический выбор единственного режима.
+
+Функциональные проверки
+- PASS all_k_r_supported: GF(256) generated every requested k+r matrix
+- PASS recover_any_r_erasures: recovered all 1208 exact-r erasure patterns
+- PASS restored_inner_byte_exact: restored Lab028 packets are byte-exact
+- PASS inner_outer_crc: outer and recovered Lab028 CRC32 checks passed
+- PASS final_partial_block_scaling: final blocks: 4+1:2+1, 8+2:6+2, 12+3:10+3, 6+2:4+2, 8+3:6+3, 4+2:2+1, 8+4:6+3
+- PASS zero_bad_100_percent: all eight modes restored 100% of frames without Bad
+- PASS fixed_seed_reproducibility: identical seed produced identical result fields
+- PASS queue_counts_parity: every parity packet is included in FIFO timing
+- PASS overload_grows_queue: 549.317 kbit/s produced queue mean/max 301.733/589
+- PASS atomic_incomplete_composite: missing final ROI fragment prevented publication
+- PASS lab030_8_2_reproduction: 8+2 exactly reproduced Lab030 order and four rows
+
+Допущения модели
+- JPEG кодируются один раз в памяти; вычислительная задержка GF(256) считается нулевой.
+- Стирается весь внешний пакет; отдельные битовые ошибки не моделируются, но оба уровня CRC проверяются.
+- Publication delay считается от frame_id/3 до конца пакета, завершившего атомарную сборку BASE+ROI.
+- No-image заканчивается публикацией следующего полного кадра или концом расписания; неполный кадр не публикуется.
+- ARQ, повторы, глубокое перемежение, команды, телеметрия, модуляция и реальный SDR отсутствуют.
+
+Артефакты
+- Полный CSV: data\processed\lab032\lab032_results.csv
+- Сводный CSV: data\processed\lab032\lab032_summary.csv
+- Отчёт: data\processed\lab032\lab032_report.txt
+- Доля восстановленных кадров: data\processed\lab032\lab032_composite_success.png
+- Скорость и избыточность: data\processed\lab032\lab032_stream_overhead.png
+- Задержка публикации: data\processed\lab032\lab032_publication_delay.png
+- Отсутствие изображения: data\processed\lab032\lab032_no_image_duration.png
+- Влияние размера блока: data\processed\lab032\lab032_block_size_effect.png
+- Практическая граница: data\processed\lab032\lab032_practical_frontier.png
+- JPEG, пакеты и бинарные дампы не сохранялись.

data/processed/lab032/lab032_results.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+mode,label,source_block_size,nominal_parity_count,code_rate,mean_bad_duration_ms,mean_good_duration_ms,target_bad_time_fraction,actual_bad_time_fraction,monte_carlo_repetitions,seed,source_jpeg_bitrate_kbps,inner_packet_stream_bitrate_kbps,outer_fec_stream_bitrate_kbps,margin_to_control_bitrate_kbps,service_and_parity_percent,control_stream_bitrate_kbps,schedule_duration_seconds,fec_block_count,final_block_source_count,final_block_parity_count,mean_block_duration_seconds,max_block_duration_seconds,mean_decode_ready_duration_seconds,mean_queue_length_packets,max_queue_length_packets,transmitted_source_packets,transmitted_parity_packets,lost_source_packets,lost_parity_packets,recovered_source_packets,fec_recovered_blocks,fec_unrecoverable_blocks,fec_affected_block_recovery_rate,fec_all_block_success_rate,fec_unrecoverable_block_rate,base_objects_completed,base_success_rate,roi_objects_completed,roi_success_rate,atomic_composite_frames_completed,composite_success_rate,base_only_frames,roi_only_frames,incomplete_frames,effective_delivered_video_bitrate_kbps,mean_publication_delay_seconds,p95_publication_delay_seconds,max_publication_delay_seconds,mean_no_new_image_duration_seconds,p95_no_new_image_duration_seconds,max_no_new_image_duration_seconds,mean_consecutive_incomplete_frames,p95_consecutive_incomplete_frames,max_consecutive_incomplete_frames
+none,Без FEC,0,0,1.0,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.020237233778310743,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,168.39601926163724,131.60398073836276,6.3102798265039075,300.0,20.869679999999992,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,13.7169373549884,15,172400,0,8130,0,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,10778,0.8553968253968254,9644,0.7653968253968254,8437,0.6696031746031746,2341,1207,4163,105.09054858531616,0.18497208960530362,0.20301333333332394,0.20967999999999998,0.8136578817966899,1.3455733333333306,3.0084000000000004,1.476241134751773,3.0,8
+4+1,4+1,4,1,0.8,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.020205583457443846,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.95928000000002,216,2,1,0.09296604938271637,0.18984000000000556,0.07760604938271627,17.17068645640074,20,172400,43200,8454,2166,2948,2948,2885,0.5054003085890623,0.9332175925925926,0.0667824074074074,11517,0.914047619047619,10717,0.8505555555555555,9972,0.7914285714285715,1545,745,2628,123.60095384955959,0.25078923118064045,0.277253333333352,0.3947733333333403,0.7504291108955716,1.0431573333333346,2.687546666666666,1.274490785645005,2.0,7
+8+2,8+2,8,2,0.8,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.02054934259858452,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,108,6,2,0.18972345679012387,0.2667200000000012,0.15900345679012368,17.209647495361782,21,172400,43200,8451,2229,5560,4070,1028,0.798352295017654,0.9524074074074074,0.047592592592592596,12102,0.9604761904761905,11797,0.9362698412698413,11502,0.9128571428571428,600,295,1098,142.6072647730782,0.2601807152379309,0.39477333333332965,0.46559999999999846,0.7307525925925931,1.0170573333333313,1.7975999999999885,1.196078431372549,2.0,4
+12+3,12+3,12,3,0.8,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.02054934259858452,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,72,10,3,0.2887951851851859,0.33717333333333244,0.24271518518518562,17.21892393320965,21,172400,43200,8382,2249,6633,4195,481,0.8971343028229256,0.9665972222222222,0.03340277777777778,12298,0.976031746031746,12141,0.9635714285714285,11995,0.9519841269841269,303,146,605,148.739525445967,0.27203066166458373,0.43695999999999735,0.5433600000000043,0.7779739823008857,1.130100000000001,1.8652533333333245,1.3384955752212389,2.0,4
+6+2,6+2,6,2,0.75,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.02054934259858452,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,242.92776886035313,57.072231139646874,35.05486837932128,300.0,20.974640000000022,144,4,2,0.14265870370370404,0.21429333333333744,0.11193870370370387,18.337391304347825,21,172400,57600,8406,2992,5902,4396,959,0.8209150326797385,0.9667013888888889,0.03329861111111111,12165,0.9654761904761905,11882,0.943015873015873,11603,0.9208730158730158,562,279,997,143.8502954043548,0.27183035421873797,0.3794133333333327,0.4374400000000094,0.7170305679592641,1.015386666666668,1.4916266666666544,1.171562867215041,2.0,3
+8+3,8+3,8,3,0.7272727272727273,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.020402467996494884,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,250.91595505617977,49.08404494382023,37.12246828058022,300.0,21.020720000000026,108,6,3,0.19185679012345724,0.2667200000000012,0.145776790123457,18.984822934232714,24,172400,64800,8524,3269,7148,4741,412,0.9200465748107899,0.980925925925926,0.019074074074074073,12377,0.9823015873015873,12259,0.972936507936508,12139,0.9634126984126984,238,120,461,150.1392511769338,0.28472546338248755,0.410133333333329,0.48210666666667734,0.7119441206030163,1.0108000000000015,1.6533066666666691,1.1582914572864322,2.0,4
+4+2,4+2,4,2,0.6666666666666666,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.020402467996494884,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.020720000000026,216,2,1,0.09639320987654372,0.1591200000000068,0.06574432098765466,20.698375870069604,24,172400,86200,8475,4327,6317,4860,936,0.8385093167701864,0.9783333333333334,0.021666666666666667,12181,0.9667460317460318,11940,0.9476190476190476,11652,0.9247619047619048,529,288,948,144.11669438534915,0.30090820688866216,0.34253333333332137,0.41933333333331824,0.6944152068696341,1.0002666666666684,1.6533066666666691,1.1100702576112411,2.0,4
+8+4,8+4,8,4,0.6666666666666666,10.0,490.0,0.02,0.019902265840707405,200,300300,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.051440000000028,108,6,3,0.1938755555555563,0.2667200000000012,0.13257777777777818,20.85924207269915,26,172400,86200,8364,4311,7797,4860,144,0.9712230215827338,0.9933333333333333,0.006666666666666667,12520,0.9936507936507937,12472,0.9898412698412699,12436,0.986984126984127,84,36,164,153.61973147680135,0.3084344440870609,0.4101333333333308,0.4963199999999981,0.7097399061032867,1.0169693333333332,1.0686133333333285,1.1549295774647887,2.0,2
+none,Без FEC,0,0,1.0,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019137425732142044,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,168.39601926163724,131.60398073836276,6.3102798265039075,300.0,20.869679999999992,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,13.7169373549884,15,172400,0,4062,0,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,12052,0.9565079365079365,11819,0.938015873015873,11523,0.9145238095238095,529,296,1077,143.55281729283826,0.18500322485463208,0.20301333333332394,0.20967999999999998,0.6934565404298871,0.9983146666666661,1.6871733333333334,1.1023541453428864,2.0,4
+4+1,4+1,4,1,0.8,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.020366888699952315,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.95928000000002,216,2,1,0.09296604938271637,0.18984000000000556,0.07760604938271627,17.17068645640074,20,172400,43200,4404,1111,435,435,1555,0.2185929648241206,0.9640046296296296,0.03599537037037037,12072,0.9580952380952381,11759,0.9332539682539682,11454,0.909047619047619,618,305,1146,142.09415018073125,0.2470573493975917,0.27522666666668627,0.394773333333335,0.714345825703629,1.0041866666666657,1.993706666666668,1.165818921668362,2.0,5
+8+2,8+2,8,2,0.8,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019947721301082785,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,108,6,2,0.18972345679012387,0.2667200000000012,0.15900345679012368,17.209647495361782,21,172400,43200,4326,1104,971,658,905,0.4209852847088932,0.9581018518518518,0.04189814814814815,12183,0.9669047619047619,11974,0.9503174603174603,11760,0.9333333333333333,423,214,840,145.76717025894112,0.24829524943310788,0.27522666666668627,0.46530666666666143,0.7125767765567773,1.009596,1.6315466666666705,1.1538461538461537,2.0,4
+12+3,12+3,12,3,0.8,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019947721301082785,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,72,10,3,0.2887951851851859,0.33717333333333244,0.24271518518518562,17.21892393320965,21,172400,43200,4368,1082,1492,799,598,0.5719398711524696,0.9584722222222222,0.041527777777777775,12273,0.974047619047619,12114,0.9614285714285714,11985,0.9511904761904761,288,129,615,148.55436660653038,0.25108506744541914,0.2925866666666561,0.5421066666666583,0.7189982697201026,1.0041866666666657,1.993706666666668,1.1736641221374047,2.0,5
+6+2,6+2,6,2,0.75,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019947721301082785,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,242.92776886035313,57.072231139646874,35.05486837932128,300.0,20.974640000000022,144,4,2,0.14265870370370404,0.21429333333333744,0.11193870370370387,18.337391304347825,21,172400,57600,4368,1480,994,687,973,0.413855421686747,0.9662152777777778,0.03378472222222222,12172,0.966031746031746,11935,0.9472222222222222,11722,0.9303174603174603,450,213,878,145.30510368711916,0.2636889040550546,0.2962933333333524,0.4374400000000094,0.7177993752788941,1.0114399999999997,1.993706666666668,1.1753681392235609,2.0,5
+8+3,8+3,8,3,0.7272727272727273,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019374042379375574,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,250.91595505617977,49.08404494382023,37.12246828058022,300.0,21.020720000000026,108,6,3,0.19185679012345724,0.2667200000000012,0.145776790123457,18.984822934232714,24,172400,64800,4293,1651,1567,863,658,0.5673898750821827,0.9695370370370371,0.030462962962962963,12280,0.9746031746031746,12107,0.9608730158730159,11955,0.9488095238095238,325,152,645,147.8507529713538,0.2735714953297101,0.3079733333333543,0.4809599999999983,0.7145212903225816,1.0080079999999976,1.3905066666666706,1.1559139784946237,2.0,3
+4+2,4+2,4,2,0.6666666666666666,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.019374042379375574,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.020720000000026,216,2,1,0.09639320987654372,0.1591200000000068,0.06574432098765466,20.698375870069604,24,172400,86200,4328,2165,1095,760,1111,0.4061998931052913,0.9742824074074075,0.025717592592592594,12133,0.962936507936508,11923,0.9462698412698413,11644,0.9241269841269841,489,279,956,144.01249053315,0.2971720302301636,0.3366666666666909,0.41933333333331824,0.7232546932006642,1.0119066666666576,1.7137333333333764,1.1890547263681592,2.0,4
+8+4,8+4,8,4,0.6666666666666666,50.0,2450.0,0.02,0.0203533945388834,200,300301,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.051440000000028,108,6,3,0.1938755555555563,0.2667200000000012,0.13257777777777818,20.85924207269915,26,172400,86200,4506,2275,2062,979,520,0.6531020680453635,0.975925925925926,0.024074074074074074,12298,0.976031746031746,12178,0.9665079365079365,12037,0.9553174603174603,261,141,563,148.6380960162343,0.29828562377115203,0.3386933333333566,0.49543999999999855,0.7492293986636983,1.0571200000000047,1.4058666666666717,1.2538975501113585,2.0,3
+none,Без FEC,0,0,1.0,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.02117165511678711,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,168.39601926163724,131.60398073836276,6.3102798265039075,300.0,20.869679999999992,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,13.7169373549884,15,172400,0,3877,0,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,12251,0.9723015873015873,12188,0.9673015873015873,12105,0.9607142857142857,146,83,495,150.88131681942423,0.18509811593005004,0.20301333333332394,0.20967999999999998,0.7862588982259566,1.3251839999999993,2.333306666666667,1.3865546218487395,3.0,6
+4+1,4+1,4,1,0.8,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01946372101257088,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.95928000000002,216,2,1,0.09296604938271637,0.18984000000000556,0.07760604938271627,17.17068645640074,20,172400,43200,3597,915,92,92,1038,0.08141592920353982,0.9759722222222222,0.024027777777777776,12262,0.9731746031746031,12183,0.9669047619047619,12092,0.9596825396825397,170,91,508,150.0674164379691,0.24658850369390367,0.27488000000001733,0.394773333333335,0.8230332549019609,1.3371666666666668,2.34952,1.4941176470588236,3.0,6
+8+2,8+2,8,2,0.8,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01945312904270856,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,108,6,2,0.18972345679012387,0.2667200000000012,0.15900345679012368,17.209647495361782,21,172400,43200,3573,908,144,101,602,0.14366998577524892,0.9721296296296297,0.027870370370370372,12283,0.9748412698412698,12214,0.9693650793650793,12134,0.963015873015873,149,80,466,150.4825408207243,0.2463296192516908,0.27506666666666346,0.4667466666666762,0.8374642185792353,1.3387466666666654,2.3341600000000007,1.5278688524590165,3.0,6
+12+3,12+3,12,3,0.8,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01945312904270856,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,72,10,3,0.2887951851851859,0.33717333333333244,0.24271518518518562,17.21892393320965,21,172400,43200,3579,903,260,131,455,0.2235494880546075,0.9684027777777777,0.03159722222222222,12295,0.9757936507936508,12238,0.9712698412698413,12168,0.9657142857142857,127,70,432,150.89903235526316,0.2465654372123616,0.2887733333333302,0.5229066666666595,0.8415958095238097,1.3391346666666688,2.380239999999999,1.542857142857143,3.0,6
+6+2,6+2,6,2,0.75,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01945312904270856,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,242.92776886035313,57.072231139646874,35.05486837932128,300.0,20.974640000000022,144,4,2,0.14265870370370404,0.21429333333333744,0.11193870370370387,18.337391304347825,21,172400,57600,3609,1180,188,127,713,0.15119047619047618,0.9752430555555556,0.024756944444444446,12268,0.9736507936507937,12204,0.9685714285714285,12112,0.9612698412698413,156,92,488,150.2020516204329,0.2623295794804066,0.29408000000000545,0.42549333333333905,0.8397175527426163,1.3339266666666698,2.3648799999999994,1.5443037974683544,3.0,6
+8+3,8+3,8,3,0.7272727272727273,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01942144600871695,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,250.91595505617977,49.08404494382023,37.12246828058022,300.0,21.020720000000026,108,6,3,0.19185679012345724,0.2667200000000012,0.145776790123457,18.984822934232714,24,172400,64800,3566,1346,249,130,562,0.18786127167630057,0.9739814814814814,0.026018518518518517,12280,0.9746031746031746,12216,0.9695238095238096,12128,0.9625396825396826,152,88,472,150.08097914819265,0.2710280233069496,0.30594666666668857,0.4667466666666762,0.8615145230078568,1.3390666666666675,2.3341600000000007,1.5892255892255893,3.0,6
+4+2,4+2,4,2,0.6666666666666666,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.01942144600871695,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.020720000000026,216,2,1,0.09639320987654372,0.1591200000000068,0.06574432098765466,20.698375870069604,24,172400,86200,3572,1806,236,159,938,0.14494074749316319,0.978287037037037,0.02171296296296296,12261,0.9730952380952381,12177,0.9664285714285714,12084,0.959047619047619,177,93,516,149.53471051419723,0.29658307403729667,0.33632000000002193,0.39477333333332965,0.8655246666666663,1.349666666666665,2.3648799999999994,1.6125,3.0,6
+8+4,8+4,8,4,0.6666666666666666,200.0,9800.0,0.02,0.019400401043555997,200,300302,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.051440000000028,108,6,3,0.1938755555555563,0.2667200000000012,0.13257777777777818,20.85924207269915,26,172400,86200,3550,1777,375,160,522,0.23460410557184752,0.9758333333333333,0.024166666666666666,12288,0.9752380952380952,12225,0.9702380952380952,12135,0.9630952380952381,153,90,465,149.94388982416385,0.2959204021425649,0.3366666666666909,0.46594666666666207,0.8995634676434676,1.347973333333331,2.3341600000000007,1.7032967032967032,3.0,6
+none,Без FEC,0,0,1.0,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017221990003688604,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,168.39601926163724,131.60398073836276,6.3102798265039075,300.0,20.869679999999992,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,13.7169373549884,15,172400,0,3014,0,0,0,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,12372,0.981904761904762,12355,0.9805555555555555,12345,0.9797619047619047,27,10,255,153.8087579684979,0.1850217642770288,0.20301333333332394,0.20967999999999998,1.4030256410256405,3.0499439999999973,4.3269600000000015,3.269230769230769,8.149999999999991,12
+4+1,4+1,4,1,0.8,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.01762954307387838,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.95928000000002,216,2,1,0.09296604938271637,0.18984000000000556,0.07760604938271627,17.17068645640074,20,172400,43200,3089,774,18,18,806,0.021844660194174758,0.9813425925925926,0.018657407407407407,12362,0.9811111111111112,12340,0.9793650793650793,12325,0.9781746031746031,37,15,275,152.8935249684148,0.24643575388776331,0.27488000000001733,0.37941333333333027,1.444222551440331,3.016560000000001,4.3107466666666685,3.3950617283950617,8.0,12
+8+2,8+2,8,2,0.8,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017631278990127012,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,108,6,2,0.18972345679012387,0.2667200000000012,0.15900345679012368,17.209647495361782,21,172400,43200,3079,781,25,16,427,0.03611738148984198,0.9802314814814815,0.01976851851851852,12366,0.9814285714285714,12342,0.9795238095238096,12327,0.9783333333333334,39,15,273,152.80692302704583,0.24594955030961974,0.27506666666666346,0.44994666666666205,1.466306160337555,3.0479386666666684,4.295386666666669,3.4556962025316458,8.099999999999994,12
+12+3,12+3,12,3,0.8,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017631278990127012,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,300.0,20.974640000000022,72,10,3,0.2887951851851859,0.33717333333333244,0.24271518518518562,17.21892393320965,21,172400,43200,3090,775,34,18,304,0.055900621118012424,0.9788888888888889,0.021111111111111112,12367,0.9815079365079366,12343,0.9796031746031746,12329,0.9784920634920635,38,14,271,152.83293157832492,0.24574732095060553,0.2850666666666548,0.5122933333333357,1.5037301754385983,3.0950066666666745,4.3368533333333215,3.5657894736842106,8.25,12
+6+2,6+2,6,2,0.75,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017631278990127012,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,242.92776886035313,57.072231139646874,35.05486837932128,300.0,20.974640000000022,144,4,2,0.14265870370370404,0.21429333333333744,0.11193870370370387,18.337391304347825,21,172400,57600,3092,1033,40,25,547,0.043706293706293704,0.9810069444444445,0.018993055555555555,12366,0.9814285714285714,12338,0.9792063492063492,12326,0.9782539682539683,40,12,274,152.79328179172546,0.26206411812429153,0.29408000000000545,0.4192266666666633,1.4673545991561199,3.047938666666669,4.336853333333321,3.4683544303797467,8.099999999999994,12
+8+3,8+3,8,3,0.7272727272727273,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017636471517506424,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,250.91595505617977,49.08404494382023,37.12246828058022,300.0,21.020720000000026,108,6,3,0.19185679012345724,0.2667200000000012,0.145776790123457,18.984822934232714,24,172400,64800,3080,1165,48,25,418,0.056433408577878104,0.9806481481481482,0.019351851851851853,12368,0.9815873015873016,12340,0.9793650793650793,12325,0.9781746031746031,43,15,275,152.44826628203012,0.27059416362407174,0.3057866666666631,0.44994666666666205,1.508938181818184,3.079317333333341,4.290773333333321,3.5714285714285716,8.200000000000003,12
+4+2,4+2,4,2,0.6666666666666666,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017636471517506424,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.020720000000026,216,2,1,0.09639320987654372,0.1591200000000068,0.06574432098765466,20.698375870069604,24,172400,86200,3094,1545,55,36,784,0.04390243902439024,0.9818518518518519,0.01814814814814815,12362,0.9811111111111112,12331,0.9786507936507937,12312,0.9771428571428571,50,19,288,152.2895466948799,0.2964339592809204,0.33632000000002193,0.39477333333333053,1.5150906666666693,3.0350866666667184,4.336853333333319,3.6,8.049999999999997,12
+8+4,8+4,8,4,0.6666666666666666,1000.0,49000.0,0.02,0.017189734334432376,200,300303,157.76975922953451,168.39601926163724,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,300.0,21.051440000000028,108,6,3,0.1938755555555563,0.2667200000000012,0.13257777777777818,20.85924207269915,26,172400,86200,3004,1509,64,27,400,0.06323185011709602,0.9814814814814815,0.018518518518518517,12372,0.981904761904762,12346,0.9798412698412698,12325,0.9781746031746031,47,21,275,152.2330861926783,0.29551052981744624,0.33650666666666273,0.46469333333333185,1.5328961403508796,3.0950066666666753,4.2754133333333195,3.6184210526315788,8.25,12

data/processed/lab032/lab032_summary.csv

@@ -0,0 +1,9 @@
+mode,label,source_block_size,nominal_parity_count,code_rate,outer_fec_stream_bitrate_kbps,margin_to_control_bitrate_kbps,service_and_parity_percent,fec_block_count,mean_block_duration_seconds,max_block_duration_seconds,mean_decode_ready_duration_seconds,mean_queue_length_packets,max_queue_length_packets,composite_success_10ms,p95_publication_delay_10ms_seconds,p95_no_new_image_10ms_seconds,composite_success_50ms,p95_publication_delay_50ms_seconds,p95_no_new_image_50ms_seconds,composite_success_200ms,p95_publication_delay_200ms_seconds,p95_no_new_image_200ms_seconds,composite_success_1000ms,p95_publication_delay_1000ms_seconds,p95_no_new_image_1000ms_seconds
+none,Без FEC,0,0,1.0,168.39601926163724,131.60398073836276,6.3102798265039075,0,0.0,0.0,0.0,13.7169373549884,15,0.6696031746031746,0.20301333333332394,1.3455733333333306,0.9145238095238095,0.20301333333332394,0.9983146666666661,0.9607142857142857,0.20301333333332394,1.3251839999999993,0.9797619047619047,0.20301333333332394,3.0499439999999973
+4+1,4+1,4,1,0.8,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,216,0.09296604938271637,0.18984000000000556,0.07760604938271627,17.17068645640074,20,0.7914285714285715,0.277253333333352,1.0431573333333346,0.909047619047619,0.27522666666668627,1.0041866666666657,0.9596825396825397,0.27488000000001733,1.3371666666666668,0.9781746031746031,0.27488000000001733,3.016560000000001
+8+2,8+2,8,2,0.8,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,108,0.18972345679012387,0.2667200000000012,0.15900345679012368,17.209647495361782,21,0.9128571428571428,0.39477333333332965,1.0170573333333313,0.9333333333333333,0.27522666666668627,1.009596,0.963015873015873,0.27506666666666346,1.3387466666666654,0.9783333333333334,0.27506666666666346,3.0479386666666684
+12+3,12+3,12,3,0.8,226.95139646869984,73.04860353130016,30.4830189704105,72,0.2887951851851859,0.33717333333333244,0.24271518518518562,17.21892393320965,21,0.9519841269841269,0.43695999999999735,1.130100000000001,0.9511904761904761,0.2925866666666561,1.0041866666666657,0.9657142857142857,0.2887733333333302,1.3391346666666688,0.9784920634920635,0.2850666666666548,3.0950066666666745
+6+2,6+2,6,2,0.75,242.92776886035313,57.072231139646874,35.05486837932128,144,0.14265870370370404,0.21429333333333744,0.11193870370370387,18.337391304347825,21,0.9208730158730158,0.3794133333333327,1.015386666666668,0.9303174603174603,0.2962933333333524,1.0114399999999997,0.9612698412698413,0.29408000000000545,1.3339266666666698,0.9782539682539683,0.29408000000000545,3.047938666666669
+8+3,8+3,8,3,0.7272727272727273,250.91595505617977,49.08404494382023,37.12246828058022,108,0.19185679012345724,0.2667200000000012,0.145776790123457,18.984822934232714,24,0.9634126984126984,0.410133333333329,1.0108000000000015,0.9488095238095238,0.3079733333333543,1.0080079999999976,0.9625396825396826,0.30594666666668857,1.3390666666666675,0.9781746031746031,0.3057866666666631,3.079317333333341
+4+2,4+2,4,2,0.6666666666666666,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,216,0.09639320987654372,0.1591200000000068,0.06574432098765466,20.698375870069604,24,0.9247619047619048,0.34253333333332137,1.0002666666666684,0.9241269841269841,0.3366666666666909,1.0119066666666576,0.959047619047619,0.33632000000002193,1.349666666666665,0.9771428571428571,0.33632000000002193,3.0350866666667184
+8+4,8+4,8,4,0.6666666666666666,274.6586195826645,25.341380417335472,42.55787075997801,108,0.1938755555555563,0.2667200000000012,0.13257777777777818,20.85924207269915,26,0.986984126984127,0.4101333333333308,1.0169693333333332,0.9553174603174603,0.3386933333333566,1.0571200000000047,0.9630952380952381,0.3366666666666909,1.347973333333331,0.9781746031746031,0.33650666666666273,3.0950066666666753